ABA Therapy Pros and Cons

Recognising the Benefits and Drawbacks of ABA Therapy: Learning from Early Research and Application

ABA treatment, or applied behaviour analysis, is a well-known method for treating autism in children. It entails applying behavioural concepts to lessen undesired behaviours and encourage good behaviour changes.

ABA treatment has proven to have many advantages, but it is not without drawbacks. The benefits and disadvantages of ABA treatment are examined in this article, which also discusses current implementation strategies and draws conclusions from earlier research, notably Lovaas' 1987 study.

Understanding ABA Therapy: A Comprehensive Evaluation

The study of learning and behaviour serves as the foundation for Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA), a type of treatment.

Acknowledged as a medically required intervention, particularly for people with autism, ABA therapy is extremely adaptable. ABA therapy can be carried out in various environments, such as homes, schools, and communities. 

Its main goal is to assist people in acquiring basic life skills, such as cleaning their teeth, putting on clothes, and cooking. ABA treatment also aims to improve social skills and lessen problematic behaviours.

Working with a qualified healthcare provider known as a Registered Behaviour Technician (RBT) is essential to ABA therapy.

These experts provide individualised ways to support learning and constructive behaviour modification while working one-on-one with adults or children. 

Board-Certified Behaviour Analysts (BCBAs), who have completed a national certification test and hold a master's degree or higher in behaviour analysis, psychology, or education, oversee RBTs. The monitoring guarantees that the therapy is efficient and customised to meet the individual's demands.

Treating patients who learn and think differently, especially those with autism spectrum disorder, is a key component of ABA therapy.

An essential part of ABA is positive reinforcement, which is crucial to this process. This strategy encourages good behavioural changes over time, assisting people in becoming more successful and independent both now and in the future.

ABA treatment has a wide range of applications; it may pinpoint the underlying causes of behavioural issues and put particular plans to deal with them.

This therapy is accessible to a broad range of people since it may be used in several settings, such as homes, schools, clinics, and hospitals.

The Antecedent-Behavior-Consequence (ABC) approach is a fundamental ABA methodology that focuses on improving individual behaviours by examining and altering the series of events that impact them.

Within the ABC technique, the stimulus or request that sets off a certain behaviour is referred to as the antecedent.

The action performed in response to the antecedent is known as the behaviour, and the response to the behaviour—which frequently takes the form of reinforcement—is known as the consequence. For example, after a meal, parents may ask their kids to clean their plates. 

The kids are rewarded for complying, which further reinforces their good behaviour. ABA therapists can improve critical skills by modifying an individual's surroundings, reactions, and reward systems by breaking down behaviours into this sequence.

The Lovaas Study: Evaluating Efficacy

Ivar Lovaas carried out a ground-breaking investigation in 1987 to evaluate the efficacy of ABA therapy for kids with autism diagnoses. 38 infants, all less than 40 months, were split into two groups for the research.

Whereas the control group only received 10 hours per week of one-on-one therapy, the experimental group received 40 hours.

Targeted skills included training academic and social skills as well as minimising aggressive and self-stimulatory behaviours during three years.

Positive Outcomes

Significant improvements were shown for the experimental group in Lovaas' study. In comparison to just 2% in the control group, almost 47% of the kids in this group attained normal intellectual and educational functioning. 

Additionally, the experimental group outperformed the control group by an average of 30 IQ points. These findings demonstrated how intense ABA therapy can lead to notable developmental gains.

Limitations and Difficulties

Notwithstanding the favourable results noted in Lovaas' research, several restrictions and difficulties were noted.

One major drawback is that it was sometimes difficult to transfer treatment improvements to other contexts, including home or school because they were frequently environment-specific. 

Furthermore, a significant setback in progress was noted at follow-up, suggesting that the advantages of ABA therapy may eventually fade in the absence of ongoing reinforcement and assistance.

Additionally, Lovaas pointed out that no client has ever been recorded as entirely healed, indicating that even while ABA therapy might produce notable gains, not all issues related to autism may be fully resolved by it. 

These drawbacks emphasise the necessity of continuous assistance and a comprehensive approach to therapy beyond the therapy sessions to ensure sustained progress and generalization of skills across various environments.

Applied Behaviour Analysis Benefits and Drawbacks

Numerous state and federal authorities, such as the New York State Department of Health and the U.S. Surgeon General, have endorsed Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA), which is largely considered a safe and effective treatment for autism. Despite its widespread use, parents and other carers should be aware of the benefits and drawbacks of ABA treatment.

Evolution of ABA Therapy

The Development of ABA Therapy ABA was first applied in 1959 to improve the functioning of patients who were mentally ill for an extended period. It has been in use for decades. Ivar Lovaas' 1987 study with 19 autistic children gave it notoriety as an autism therapy. 

According to this study, 40 hours a week of intense ABA therapy resulted in notable gains for the children, many of whom integrated into mainstream schools and tested intelligently at or above average. Since then, ABA has become more well-liked, and it is currently a widely used treatment nationwide.

Pros of ABA Therapy

Studies Back Up ABA's Effectiveness as a Treatment

ABA has been the subject of much research, with consistently positive results in the treatment of autism. Numerous reviews, including those by Hingtgen & Bryson (1972) and Baglio et al. (1996), have shown how beneficial ABA is in helping children achieve several goals.

Well-trained Professionals

Typically possessing a master's degree or more, ABA therapists undergo comprehensive formal training in behavioural analysis. The ABA programs are closely monitored, and therapists adhere to precise treatment protocols while tracking participants' advancement.

Personalization ABA Program

ABA programs are tailored to meet each child's unique needs. To create specialised programs that target certain areas where a child needs assistance, such as social skills, academic abilities, and behaviour management, therapists do in-depth examinations and observations.

The Effectiveness of ABA Is Based on Research

Government and commercial groups worldwide advocate ABA therapy because of the vast body of research that supports it. For example, the U.S. Surgeon General supports ABA as the best treatment for autism since it has been shown to improve socialisation, communication, and learning in children with severe instances.

Easy for Parents to Learn

Parents participate in the therapeutic process with ABA therapy. Numerous clinics provide parents with instruction, teaching them how to assist their child's development both at home and at school. The child's social skills, listening comprehension, and behaviour control may all increase through this interaction.

Early Recognition and Treatment of Symptoms

Because of their in-depth expertise in psychology, ABA therapists can identify and treat autism signs at an early age. Better long-term results, including enhanced social and academic performance, can result from early intervention, as well as a speedier recovery.

Parental Participation

Parental engagement in treatment decisions is encouraged by ABA therapy. Clinics frequently accommodate parents' wishes by letting them select or alter the programmes offered to their kids.

Boosts Cognitive and Skill Levels

ABA treatment is beneficial for enhancing several skills, such as social interaction, communication, and cognitive functioning. ABA helps children acquire critical motor and analytical abilities and improves learning settings by addressing behavioural concerns such as tantrums.

Reduced Number of Absentees from School

By assisting children in coping with social demands and disruptive behaviours, ABA treatment can lower the number of days missed from school. Through friendship-building and teacher connection, this treatment helps kids have a better school experience.

Cons of Applied Behaviour Analysis

Cost and Time May Be Exorbitant

40 hours of ABA each week were required for Lovaas's study, which is a time- and money-consuming commitment. A large portion of families must pay for such intense therapy out of pocket as many school systems lack the funding to offer it, and insurance policies differ. Programmes with fewer hours, however beneficial, might not show effects right away.

Having Trouble Locating Reputable Therapists in Some Areas

While most ABA therapists have extensive training, in certain places it might be tough to locate licenced practitioners. Because there are no uniform licencing requirements, anybody may pretend to be an ABA therapist, even if they are not certified.

Parents need to carefully verify the credentials of therapists, frequently confirming with the Behaviour Analyst Certification Board.

Robotic Results

Advocates contend that because ABA exercises are repeated, they might lead to robotic behaviours and inhibit autonomous thought. On the other hand, supporters assert that these early rote exercises aid in the acquisition of fundamental social skills in youngsters, which eventually become more instinctive.

Time taken can Vary

The time that ABA therapy takes varies greatly; some cases take weeks, while others take years. Parents who are used to seeing faster improvement may find this unpredictable. Counsellors stress that ABA is a nonlinear procedure that calls for persistence and patience.

Depending on the program's severity, annual costs for expensive ABA therapy might range from $62,400 to $249,600. Even while ABA must be covered by insurance in many areas when a doctor prescribes it, many families may find the high expenses prohibitive.

Long and Timely Courses

An average of 10 hours a week, with the potential to reach 40 hours, is needed to participate in ABA programs. Families may find it difficult to reconcile therapy appointments with work and school schedules, which makes it more difficult to attend sessions.

Effects on Individual Cases Can Conflict with Research

Because ABA therapy is tailored for each patient, results may differ and counter more general study conclusions. Because of this heterogeneity, therapists find it challenging to forecast treatment outcomes and must make personalised modifications during therapy.

Conclusion

Numerous advantages of ABA treatment include its well-documented efficacy, personalised programs, and parental engagement. However, there are a lot of obstacles to overcome, like the high cost, time commitment, and inconsistent outcomes.

When thinking about ABA for their kid, parents need to examine these benefits and drawbacks so that they may make the best decision for their child's needs and family situation.

Contact us

We would love to help you and your child out in every way possible. Fill out the form and lets start a beautiful journey.

I have read and agree to Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy.